Heart to Heart with Hads

Ep. 43 | Why You're Addicted to Starting Over (and how to fix it!)

Hadlea Shaw

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 11:24

Why we're addicted to starting over and how this cycle prevents us from achieving our goals. Our tendency to restart every Monday or at the beginning of months creates a false sense of progress while actually keeping us stuck in the same patterns.

• Identifying with struggle gives us an excuse to avoid the pressure of success
• The clean slate feeling is addictive but creates fake momentum rather than real progress
• Discipline takes longer than a month to build and requires consistency through boredom
• Lacking clarity about what we truly want makes it easier to quit when things get difficult
• Taking ownership of our actions instead of blaming external circumstances is essential
• Confusing planning and restarting with actual progress keeps us from execution
• Breaking promises to ourselves damages self-trust and leads to more self-sabotage
• Making decisions based on fleeting emotions rather than commitments holds us back
• Discipline isn't restrictive—it's actually freeing because it aligns actions with goals
• There's no perfect Monday coming—only today matters

Don't be addicted to starting over. Keep staying in it when things get hard.


Apply for 1:1 Health Coaching

Welcome and Topic Introduction

Speaker 1

Hello everybody and welcome back to another episode of Heart Tart with had . Today we're just going to jump right into it because we've got a lot to discuss , but the main thing , the main topic we're talking about here is to is about why you're addicted to starting over , and a lot of us are addicted to starting over on a Monday . Or we'll start at the new month , or we'll start here , start over here , and the reality is is that's , that's what's holding you back ? So we're going to talk about why , why this comes up , why you act like this and how

Addicted to the Struggle

Speaker 1

to end it . So number one talking point here is you low-key , like the struggle , and I think a lot of people like the struggle .

Speaker 1

You know how , whenever somebody asks you , okay , like how are you doing ? And you're like , oh good , or somebody compliments you , you're like oh good , but . Or somebody compliments you and you're like , thanks , I know , I'm not whatever , instead of just actually taking that compliment . I know that's not a struggle , but it kind of is , because whenever you associate or somebody asks you or I don't know what this is making sense , but hopefully it kind of does . But whenever you are dealing with something or somebody asks you for something , and you're like , oh , how are you doing your moping around ? I do this all the time . So I'm like , oh , are you OK ? And I'm like , yeah , but I'm tired today .

Speaker 1

But , like , I always find something to pick out that's negative , that's a struggle , when in reality , like , everything's fine , I'm just finding something because I want that , that sort of attention or that sort of like sympathy . And the thing is is like you're you , you define yourself , you identify with the struggle . You're just gonna continuously keep making that happen . So stop making yourself be or have like a struggle . Even if , like , even if you are struggling , like , stop making it about the struggle . Sorry , that was just kind of rude Like , but it's for real . Anyways , struggling gives you a sense of identity . If you're struggling , you never have to have the pressure of winning . And this is so true because winning is something that is hard . And when we get to the top , or we get to where we want to be , when we're winning in whatever it is winning in life or winning in our job or we constantly want to pick out a struggle , even if everything's going right , we think that we need to pick something out , pick out a struggle , and the reality is we just don't need to be doing that . The struggle keeps you safe from change , because that requires responsibility . Change requires some sort of responsibility , and if you're not willing to make that change within yourself , then you're just letting yourself down . You're not holding yourself responsible or accountable for the things that you need to be doing . So that's my last little tangent on that .

Speaker 1

The next thing , too , is you're obsessed with that clean slate feeling that comes up every single Monday or every single

The Clean Slate Trap

Speaker 1

new year . Monday is your drug Hitting . Restart feels productive , but it's actually just fake momentum . It feels so much easier to restart than to just stay consistent through that messy middle . Let me repeat that again it's easier to restart than to just stay consistent in the messy middle . You mess up , say for example , you mess up your eating on a Thursday . So instead of just making a better choice at the next meal , you just binge all weekend because you're like oh it's Thursday , friday , saturday , sunday is coming around and I can just restart on Monday . That's the exact reason you're stuck and you're not making progress in any of your goals . This can be anything like this doesn't have to be fitness related , but seriously , come on . You want that dopamine hit of a fresh start , more than the boring work of just fixing it right now . That's the harsh reality that we all need to sit with , because the thing about it is is that clean slate feeling , that fresh start feeling . The more that you rewire and or the more that you keep doing that , week after week after week , the more that just becomes who you are , that becomes your identity , that becomes the thing that you continuously do . So , anyways , that's just my take on that . All right , let's get into the .

Speaker 1

Let's get into number three . You don't have real discipline

Developing True Discipline

Speaker 1

yet . That's the hard truth . You're not . You're not disciplined yet . You say you are because you have been for a month , but the reality is it takes longer than a month to build up a foundation of discipline . You're great when you're motivated , but the thing is is motivation is ever fleeting Like ? Motivation is never going behind . This whole week I've not been motivated to do a damn thing , for whatever reason . I'm not quite sure . But just because I'm not motivated doesn't mean I didn't make it happen . So you're great when you're motivated , but when it gets , but not when it gets boring . So you have to keep continuing that momentum whenever things get boring , for example , deep down , you think what if I give it my all and then it still doesn't work , like you give it your all for one whole month and then it doesn't work ? Quitting early is protecting you from finding out if it really works . It keeps you safe from disappointment .

Speaker 1

Another thing , too you really lack clarity on what you're actually chasing . You have no real vision . Maybe you're basing your vision or ideas or the goals that you want off of things you see online or things that other people are doing , but deep down , you haven't actually sat with yourself , and especially

Taking Ownership of Your Actions

Speaker 1

in silence . You haven't actually sat down and thought about what you want . What is something that you really want ? You haven't envisioned your future . You don't even know what you want that to look like . And until you can figure out what you want that to look like , you can't make decisions on the fly . You cannot do little things on the fly . You don't have a real vision that's bigger than the next week , the next seven days . Without a long-term identity shift , you're just going to keep living for short term emotion . The long-term change comes with long-term commitment , and if you're not willing to make that long-term commitment for the long-term change that you're after , then you're just not going to , you're not going to see that end goal , that end result , come to fruition . Result come to fruition .

Speaker 1

Next thing you don't take ownership when you fall off . You simply blame everybody else around you , because that's easier than just than really taking ownership of yourself . You blame your schedule , your emotions , your job , your kids , whatever it is . You blame other people , but you don't actually take ownership or accountability for your actions . In your actions , your emotions , the way you react to things are the only things that you can control . So stop blaming on other people . That's not going to make anything better . Ownership means taking back your power , even when it's convenient , even when things don't go your way . And I'm not saying that you need to sit here and be perfect , but it's about being someone who actually finishes what they start . If you can finish what you start , that , for one , is going to build your confidence and , for two , you're not going to be wanting to start over every Monday because you've already have it built up to just keep showing up Even when you do fall . That's , that's the real shift , that's

Chasing Feelings vs. Embracing Reality

Speaker 1

the biggest shift here .

Speaker 1

Another thing is you love the idea of being someone new , but you literally hate the work that it takes to get there . For example , say you buy , you know you buy the new supplements , you buy the new workout clothes , you buy the new , the new journal , whatever it is , but three weeks in and then it's not fun anymore . It's been , it's monotonous , it's boring . You quit . You are chasing the feelings of change but not the reality of what it is . Because Because the reality is is change , is is boring , and if you can stick out and do the same thing every single time , then you will win .

Speaker 1

Another thing , too , is you probably convince action with progress . You think like you , rewriting your workout plan 10 times but still not . Still don't feel like sticking to a single week of it . You think that's , that's progress , but it's not planning . Redoing and restarting feels like you're working , but you're just avoiding the execution of the boring and monotonous . Like I have already said so many new times , you haven't built proof with yourself yet either . You've broken promises to yourself so many times that you don't even trust that this time is going to be different . So you self-sabotage because it just feels easier to fail right now than be disappointed later . Let me say that again it's easier for you to fail now than to just be disappointed later .

Speaker 1

And lastly but not leastly , which doesn't even make sense , you let all of your emotions make

Making Today Matter, Not Monday

Speaker 1

your decisions . Oh my gosh , I'm tired , I'm stressed , I'm overwhelmed . I can't do it , I can't stick to the plan because I'm so tired . So you just quit . You quit because these fleeting emotions that won't be there tomorrow or maybe in the next day , so you quit . But guess what ? If you want to be successful , if you want to make progress towards your goals , it doesn't care how you feel , you still have to show up anyway . That's so cliche , but it's so true .

Speaker 1

Another , instead of power . You think that discipline is rigid and boring and restricted , but when in reality , discipline is literally the most freeing feeling that you'll ever , that you'll ever have the most freeing thing you'll ever be able to build . So you haven't made yourself , your future you , actually your future self a non-negotiable . Yet the current you is always louder than the future you . Let me say that again the current you is always stuck in the current you . Until your future self matters more than your current comfort , you're just going to keep starting over . You're not tired of failing . You're tired of half-assing your life and wondering why nothing sticks . There's no perfect Monday . There's no perfect new month coming to save you . There's literally only today . Handle it . That's all I've got to say for today . So hope you guys liked my little notebook , my notebook thoughts this week and in the meantime , don't freaking be addicted to starting over . Keep staying in it when that shit's hard . Okay , all right , love you guys . Bye .